The news site of Marquette High School

Marquette Messenger

The news site of Marquette High School

Marquette Messenger

The news site of Marquette High School

Marquette Messenger

Andrew’s Approach: New law on student-teacher internet relations is useless

 

A lot of time is spent on Facebook these days, especially by high school students. It is notorious for becoming the most common median for procrastination. Many a student has said they will get on Facebook for a few minutes before starting their homework, and don’t get off for two hours.

 

This, of course, will lead to a lot of internet contact people may or may not want. But at the same time, Facebook and other social networking sites provide students will many opportunities to communicate with teachers and coaches. It is for this reason that forcing districts to set policies regarding teacher-student relations on social networking sites is a futile and useless attempt to curtail sexual harassment that begins on Facebook.

 

The Amy Hestir Davis Student Protection Act may have good intentions, but its reasoning is flawed.

 

The bill states that districts may set their own policies regarding teacher student contact in an attempt to curtail child abuse by teachers.

 

As good as this may sound, one realizes it is flawed when they realize that social networking sites are only a median for those who may have evil intentions with students.

 

And yes, the kind of activity the law tries to prevent is evil, but it is also true that it is impossible to legislate the pedophile out of someone. If a teacher actually has a desire to hurt children, they will most likely try to find another way to do it other than Facebook, Twitter or any other social networking site.

 

In addition to simply not producing the desired effect, the bill addresses something that simply does not need to be addressed. The bill states that districts must have a policy for student-teahcer contact.

 

It is ridiculous for the state to require a policy in an attempt to prevent sexual harassment because so few of teachers are sexual predators. In this sense, the bill is a bit of an overreaction.

 

The law may do more harm than good, as it may end necessary contact between athletes and coaches, for example, in an attempt to curtail child abuse. Athletes and coaches may need to communicate information to one another such as practice times. But if a district so chooses, it may outlaw this kind of contact.

Donate to Marquette Messenger
$15
$625
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation will support the student journalists of Marquette High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs. You may become a PATRON by making a donation at one of these levels: White/$30, Green/$50, Blue/$100. Patron names will be published in the print newsmagazine, on the website and once per quarter on our social media accounts.

About the Contributor
Andrew Bemus
Andrew Bemus, Opinions Editor
Andrew is seasoned veteran of the newspaper.  This is third and final year on  staff as a senior.  Andrew participates in NHS, Young Conservatives Club, and Youth in Government.  He's also on the track and cross country teams.  Out of school, Andrew is involved in Boy Scouts.  His favorite food is wings, and he likes to watch Seinfeld.  Andrew enjoys very much the ability to share his opinion in every issue of the Messenger.  Bemus 2032!
Donate to Marquette Messenger
$15
$625
Contributed
Our Goal